A brand new railroad would join the oil fields of northeastern Utah to the nationwide rail system
A Texas railroad firm plans to route crude oil trains from Utah’s Uinta Basin via Gore Canyon alongside the Colorado River close to Kremmling. (Jason Blevins/The Colorado Solar)
It appears to be like extremely doubtless that heated wagons loaded with a waxy crude will roll via Colorado after the Forest Service final week dismissed objections to the proposed new rail line in a bit of Utah’s roadless forest.
“We’ll proceed to combat this horrific challenge with any means at our disposal,” mentioned Deeda Seed of the Middle for Organic Range, which has been preventing for years to cease the proposed Uinta Basin Railway, an 85-mile stretch of a brand new railroad that might join the oil fields of northeastern Utah to the nationwide rail system.
A consortium of environmental teams earlier this yr objected to the Forest Service’s draft plan that can permit the brand new railroad to traverse about 12 miles of roadless territory with new bridges and tunnels in Ashley Nationwide Forest. Final week, the company dismissed these objections, ruling that the Federal Floor Transportation Board’s year-long environmental influence assertion, which accepted the brand new railroad in December 2020, adequately addresses environmental issues.
“In our view, the totality and nature of the fairly foreseeable environmental impacts have been absolutely and clearly disclosed,” wrote Deborah Oakeson, the Forest Service’s assistant regional forest warden, within the July 5 environmental evaluation to environmental group advocates.
That was a closing regulatory hurdle for Deutsche Bahn supporters. Houston-based Drexel Hamilton Infrastructure Companions and railroad operator Rio Grande Pacific Corp. plan to construct the $1.5 billion railroad for Utah’s Seven County Infrastructure Coalition, which has spent years finding out easy methods to ship the viscous, waxy crude oil from the Uinta Basin to refineries on the Gulf Coast. The plan may transfer as much as 350,000 barrels a day — as much as 5 billion gallons a yr — in railroad automobiles, which should be heated to maintain the crude from solidifying. The crude oil is just too viscous to move via a pipeline and manufacturing has been restricted by rules limiting the variety of oil vans.
When the railroad is constructed, it’ll hook up with the Union Pacific rail line, which runs alongside the Colorado River from Grand Junction via Glenwood Springs and Gore Canyon to Granby after which via the Fraser River Valley via the Moffat Tunnel to Boulder County and Denver.
A 500-year rain occasion in July 2021 despatched mud and particles over the Union Pacific railroad tracks and into the Colorado River in Glenwood Canyon alongside Interstate 70. (Hugh Carey/The Colorado Solar)
Earlier this yr, Eagle County joined a number of environmental teams to enchantment towards the Floor Transportation Board’s approval of the Uinta Basin Railroad. That enchantment, filed with the US Circuit Court docket of Appeals in Washington, DC, argues the board failed to analyze the oblique results of oil prepare visitors on the Colorado River and communities alongside the river hall.
Rio Grande Pacific Corp., which is tasked with working the railroad, requested the Floor Transportation Board in 2020 for an expedited evaluation of a plan to open the long-dormant Tennessee Move Line, which runs from Dotsero to Cañon Metropolis. Many communities and environmental teams alongside this route strongly opposed the concept of rail service on the mountainous railroad that meanders alongside the Arkansas River from Leadville to Pueblo. Rio Grande Pacific Corp’s newly fashioned Colorado Midland & Pacific Railway Co. promised to not carry oil on the rails and solely carry passengers and non-hazardous items on the railway, which closed in 1997 after a sequence of derailments. The floor authority denied expedited approval in March 2021, forcing Rio Grande Pacific to bear a prolonged environmental evaluation if it hopes to revive rail service over Tennessee Move.
“Daring Actions to Restore Forests”
Two weeks in the past, the pinnacle of the US Division of Agriculture and the pinnacle of the US Forest Service launched a memo saying the company would take “daring motion to revive forests, enhance resilience and handle the local weather disaster.”
The Forest Service’s new push for “instant and near-term motion to construct carbon stewardship and local weather resilience” within the nationwide forests was in response to President Joe Biden’s govt order to strengthen the nationwide forests via wildfire containment, ecosystem restoration and reforestation strengthen.
“However right here is the company that has absolute discretion to cease a challenge that can considerably contribute to the local weather disaster, however chooses to do nothing and actually pours gasoline on the fireplace that’s the local weather disaster. Alarm bells are ringing,” mentioned Seed, whose group sued in Utah state court docket final yr to dam the railroad challenge, arguing the railroad challenge illegally used funds from the state’s mineral leasing account to authorize the brand new railroad when These funds had been meant to influence the mineral extraction.
Mark Michel, co-founder and managing associate of Drexel Hamilton Infrastructure Companions, mentioned there may be “an insatiable want and need, not simply amongst vitality shoppers right here in the USA, however all over the world, for a secure provide and elevated reliability of… vitality alternatives. “
Utah is “extraordinarily blessed to have the geological energy” to have entry to this kind of crude oil, Michel instructed the Seven County Infrastructure Coalition throughout a listening to on the Utah Statehouse on Friday.
Michel mentioned his crew has seen elevated demand for this waxy crude from oil refiners keen to provide home vitality, in addition to demand from producers of cosmetics, lubricants and plastics.
“The market has responded and I actually assume it was a beautiful alternative as an American developer to deliver this product to market to handle the safety wants of our allies throughout Europe and Asia and to satisfy the vitality wants of People,” Michel instructed the coalition, describing the railroad “as an important challenge for the nationwide safety of this nation”.
A passenger prepare travels via Gore Canyon alongside the Colorado River in November. A proposed new railroad in Utah may route heated oil trains via the distant canyon on the identical tracks. (Jason Blevins/Colorado Solar)
Keith Heaton, the manager director of the coalition, mentioned: “We’d do a number of good with these merchandise if we may solely get them to market.”
“The world might be a greater place, each ecologically and economically, with these merchandise,” Heaton mentioned.
Coalition board member Jack Lytle, a commissioner from Daggett County, Utah, certainly one of seven counties engaged on constructing the railroad, mentioned the coalition’s multi-year work on the railroad is “an incredible mannequin for the state and different commissions, like issues might be accomplished”.
“That may be duplicated,” Lytle mentioned.
Opponents of the railroad estimate that the manufacturing and use of Uinta Basin crude oil may enhance US greenhouse gasoline emissions by 1%. After which there are issues about heated oil rolling up greater than 200 miles of the Colorado River via Colorado.
“Approving that is the other of taking daring motion,” mentioned Ted Zukoski, an lawyer with the Middle for Organic Range who organized the lawsuit filed with the US Circuit Court docket of Appeals. “It is simply wonderful. Our authorities’s priorities usually are not tackling the local weather disaster. It is about submitting to the ability of the oil and gasoline trade. There’s a discrepancy between the rhetoric and motion of this authorities.”
Environmental teams may file a lawsuit difficult the Forest Service’s closing approval of the railroad via Ashley Nationwide Forest. After which there are the lawsuits in Washington and Utah that would halt or decelerate the challenge. However maybe environmental teams’ finest hope lies within the market, the place traders may be cautious about long-term fossil gasoline investments.
“That is an costly factor to construct,” mentioned Seed, who referred to as the initially projected $1.5 billion building price “a big underestimate” given current financial modifications. “The place will the cash come from? There’s a actual concern that they are going to begin building and never end it. Or it’s constructed after which not used.”
The Colorado Solar is a reader-supported, neutral information group devoted to reporting on points in Colorado. To be taught extra, go to coloradosun.com.